Funny story (okay, maybe not so funny)

February 10th, 2008 by jennemede

Today, at our Chinese New Year party, I heard a most disturbing story.

A friend of mine, someone who lives in our small community, made an appointment to visit a doctor a few weeks ago, at one of the two biggest healthcare institutions here in Washington, which had a branch office in our little town. My friend was eight minutes late and was promptly told by the receptionist that the appointment was, hence, cancelled.

Eight minutes late, folks. By THEIR clock.

Angry but not wanting to pursue the matter, my friend then asked for the phone to call her husband, who had dropped her off at the doctor’s office. The receptionist said no because the number was a Utah number (they’d not changed it since their move), and the office phones could not be used to call outstation. My friend then asked if the receptionist would lend her a cell phone because her husband would not return until 50 minutes later and she did not want to wait that long. The lady said no. My friend then offered to pay her back for the phone call. The lady, again, said no. Becoming increasingly frustrated but still calm, my friend then asked to make another appointment. There was a slot open at 2.30pm that afternoon. My friend agreed, but noticed that the receptionist did not seem to be writing anything down in her little appointment book.

That afternoon, my friend returned to the doctor’s office at 2.32pm. The receptionist looked at her and said, “You’re late.”

My friend answered, “I am two minutes late.”

“You are 20 minutes late,” the lady replied. “Your appointment was at 2.15pm.”

Long story short, my friend and the receptionist, along with the two other desk clerks present, exchanged some heated words.

After a few minutes, the clerks simply left the front desk and retreated into the office, leaving my friend to fume at the lobby alone. When they did not return, my friend took the hint and left.

When this story was related to me by my friend today, I could feel nothing but a sad, reddening anger. As I listened, I was struck dumb by the fact that this had happened just weeks ago, and not ten years ago, and in my town, and not some Godforsaken place a million miles away. In fact, the clinic she had visited is just a one-minute brisk walk away from my house, two in the cold Seattle rain.

What interests me about this story is that my friend is an Iranian. She has long, dark hair and beautiful, serious black eyes. She wraps around her American English a thick Middle Eastern accent, perhaps with a hint of Eastern European (her Hungarian husband’s). To a stranger, she may look severe and unapproachable but my friend is by far the funniest person I know here in America. Her humour is self-deprecating, her wit razor-sharp and her honesty humbling, and ultimately, she can be described as the best kind of surprise one can ever find underneath a perpetually furrowed brow.

What saddens me is that, no matter how much I want not to jump into conclusions about anything, a big part of me believes that this is a case of racism and discrimination. Why? Because like it or not, there are still people out there who are just plain idiots. These people are everywhere - small town America or big city Asia. They look at a person, they look at their clothes, listen to their accents and make judgments and summations and peg you as what they think you are so as to be able to survive the next few minutes without submitting into fear or anger or hatred and losing all control. Or they just do what they do to make themselves feel better.

I was in Hong Kong many years ago on assignment, and I’d walked into a noodle shop for dinner one evening. Not being able to read a single Chinese word on the menu, which was made up of pieces of coloured paper stuck on the walls, I’d looked across to the next table and noticed a lady eating some sort of chicken curry. I decided to take the easy way out and pointed to it to the ‘waiter’.

Presumably a Hong Kong Chinese, he smirked and as he walked back to the kitchen, muttered in Cantonese, “Chinese person, can’t even speak Chinese. What kind of Chinese is that?”

The fact was I could (and still can) speak Chinese and I could understand what he said. I just can’t read it and did not want to risk ordering the wrong thing. But what did he care? He’d made a snap judgment about me which I was never going to correct without making a fool of myself. And those ladies at the clinic, in my opinion, made a snap judgment about my friend, who was made a fool that day when they’d all walked out of the reception. The difference here is that I may have deserved a little of what I got, being a ‘banana‘ and everything. Did my friend deserve the sort of treatment she was subjected to, as though she’d been a plain criminal? How else can you explain why she, of all people, was treated in that manner? Was it really random? Were all three of the nurses having a bad day? And twice in one day?

I’m almost tempted to make an appointment there myself (living right next door and all) and then be eight minutes late, to see if I’d be treated the same way.

I don’t know. I just might.

Posted in Imperfect America

6 Responses

  1. adrienne

    I would recommend you contact the head of the whole system (CEO, president, etc.) and tell them that you want them to be aware that their staff treated a client with at best cruel indifference and at worst- outright racism. If other friends are concerned by the incidents, I would get them to call too. [You might want to mention that your professional background is in journalism.]

    In the face of this kind of hateful nonsense in large bureaucracies, the best reaction is to bring unexpected & unwanted executive scrutiny on the perpetrators. No corporate organization in America can afford to be labeled racist- and corporate leaders know it only takes on a-hole employee to earn that title. Ask what actions will be taken and for a follow-up call on the situation.

    I suspect there may be something illegal about the whole “policy” unless it’s in writing somewhere else.

    Our pediatrics clinic has posted loads of signs that if you are over 15 minutes late, your appointment will be rescheduled. This makes me think that such policies must be shown in writing (either in written office policies or prominently displayed in the office).

    Kick their butts… and if you don’t get satisfaction after initial efforts- please post executive contact information here- some of us in other states have time, anger, and extra cell minutes.

  2. kl_gal

    My dua sen is to get some Caucasian friend to do what you’re thinking about..schedule an appointment with them and be 8 mins late. If they treated him/her differently then your Iranian friend, write them a letter re the incident and send a copy to the newspapers. If they’re racist assh**es, they may treat you crappily too if you went ( for different but obvious reasons)

  3. Rachael

    What horrible treatment! I would definately lodge a complain. On the other hand, I wonder if the dr’s staff feels strongly about the Iraq war and is feeling a hatred toward the middle easterners. Still.. it’s not right of them to do that..

    Since so far, we’re lucky to not experience any racism treatment yet. At most, similiar with your HK experience but from a mandarin speaking chinese. Yeah right.. lol.. like I can’t understand a single word he just said. I answered him back in Penang Hokkien and with a glare. I think he’s got my message lol.

  4. judy

    I’ve been a silent reader but felt like i needed to comment on this post. I,too, agree that your friend should report that receptionist behavior to her superior because she was simply ignorant and rude. Please tell your friend to find another doctor whose staff have better manners.
    I,too,have a similar experience in HongKong. I simply told that person in cantonese that I’m from Malaysia and can’t read chinese. He was more understanding after that.

  5. Rita Ho

    Jenn … The resident doctor is Chinese, “banana” probably, so you are likely to be treated well. I was there once for a cold and didn’t encounter any rude receptionist. David was with me though. It is sad if his color indeed forced them to be polite to me.

    I agree with everyone that their shocking and disgusting behavior warrants a complaint. Their HQ in Kirkland pride themselves on excellent customer service and actually offers it. I would be surprised if they do not take action when they know.

  6. farina

    hmm if it happens once, maybe its really bcoz she was late but it happened again, later in the same day. hate to say this but tht sounds like racism to me.

    im w kl_gal. get a caucasian friend to do the same and see wht their action would be.

Leave a Comment

Please note: Comment moderation is enabled and may delay your comment. There is no need to resubmit your comment.

About The I’mPerfect Mom

30-something mom from Malaysia, trying to get off her fat arse to lose the fat arse, and write something worth reading. Any minute now.